I Am Not What I Am: Orson Welles’ Othello (1952)



Othello (1952) marked the beginning of Orson Welles’ exile from Hollywood, its funding provided by an Italian businessman soon to go bankrupt. It was the first of endless financing troubles that would plague his prolific years abroad. After he made the budget-strapped studio bound Macbeth (1948) for Republic, he was eager to make a full dress Shakespeare adaptation with elaborate sets designed by Alexandre Trauner. When the cash disappeared, he improvised, with Trauner becoming a location scout while locals were hired to sew period-appropriate clothing. The itinerant production moved between in four towns in Morocco and five in Italy. Shot over the course of two years, as Welles took on acting jobs to raise money, the film is a dizzying patchwork. Welles adapts his style to the circumstances, mostly abandoning the long takes so admired by Andre Bazin, and turning to rapid, jarring edits to sew the disparate material together. It was the first time he had final cut since Citizen Kane, and the result is vertiginous and disorienting, both a reflection of Othello’s deteriorating psyche and the jury-rigged nature of the film’s production.

A new 2K scan of the controversial 1992 restoration is now touring the United States courtesy of Carlotta Films, and has began its run at Film Forum in NYC and the Gene Siskel Film Center in Chicago (see all the future venues here). The original score and sound effects were re-recorded, an attempt to bring a 1950s film up to 1990s technical standards that replaced the audio instead of preserving what Welles produced (read Jonathan Rosenbaum for more details). With that caveat stated, this strange and hypnotic movie has never looked better.


After he completed shooting Macbeth in July of 1947, Welles went to France to develop an adaptation of Cyrano de Bergerac with his production designer Alexandre Trauner. Welles recounts that project’s implosion in his essayistic documentary Filming Othello (1978):

suddenly Alexander Korda, who was our producer, came to me and said, “my dear fellow I need dollars. I want to sell it to America.” He did, Jose Ferrer played it and got the Academy Award, and that’s the end of that story. It was supposed to be commercial, and it wasn’t, it was supposed to make me rich, and it didn’t.

So instead Welles took an acting job as the occultist Cagliostro in Black Magic (1949), which was made at Scalera Film Studios in Rome. There he found a potential patron in Michele Scalera, who agreed to fund his Othello, although he pushed for an Italian cast in order to receive grants from the government. Welles had already cast Italian actress Lea Padovani as Desdemona, with whom he was pursuing a very public romance. Their relationship became instant tabloid fodder. Padovani recalled that:

A genius like that does nothing by halves, and for him love was a delirium…. He was capable of unforgettable things. One day at the Caffe Cipriani in Venice he got down on his knees, kissed the edge of my skirt, and pronounced my name quietly. I was breathless with emotion.


Their affair was brief and ended noisily – she reportedly knocked him out with a door stopper. Regardless of the details of their affair, she was off the movie. In his new book Orson Welles in Italy Alberto Anile reports that Welles was forced to trash the film he had shot with Padovani, reported by the Venetian press as 3,000 meters, or one hour and fifty minutes of material. He then had to re-trench and re-envision the movie, while Scalera was conning the Italian government. Scalera applied for a permit to shoot Othello in English and Italian, and listed Vittorio de Sica and Gina Lollobrigida among the cast to pass the Italian actor quota, despite the fact they would not appear in the film. At this time Betsy Blair, Gene Kelly’s wife, had become the nominal Desdemona, and was in Mogador when Welles heard the news that Scalera was withholding funding, and that the period costumes would be held up in storage. The common story is that Scalera went bankrupt, but Anile writes that though he was losing money, Scalera was not broke. It was a power play to get Welles to leave Africa and return to Italy so he could maintain more control over the production.


Scalera’s ruse failed, as Welles and his team kept finding creative solutions to their money problems. They famously shot Roderigo’s death scene in a Turkish bath, so there was no need for the costumes, while a thick wall of steam obscured their sparsely detailed set. While the idea has always been attributed to Welles, Blair recalls that it was conceived by Trauner, whom she saw sketching the concept and pitching it to Welles, who ecstatically agreed to it. No matter who the idea originated with, it represents the openness of Welles’ team and his artistic credo. Welles said, “It’s a basic part of the way I work with a group of people — I always move. Not because I’m patient, but because of what I think will happen to the picture if I don’t.” Another of those movements was firing Blair and finally settling on Canadian actress Suzanne Cloutier as Desdemona. Welles was afraid of rigidity setting in, and always kept the production moving forward, even if it was in a series of herky jerky stops and starts.


Eventually Scalera withdrew the remainder of his funds unless Welles returned to Italy, but the stubborn director was committed to his new vision. Enough so he began to fund it out of his own pocket from money earned at acting jobs (Prince of Foxes, The Black Rose). When watching Othello a single cut can span both years and continents. Despite the stressful, ad hoc circumstances, the film is remarkably single-minded in its visual scheme. It moves from the bright coastal light of the Mogador coast to the darkening cell interiors of Othello’s Moroccan castle. Latticework-spiderweb imagery abounds, each character crisscrossed by shadow and then further sliced by the aggressive editing, which never seems to let bodies complete a motion before cutting to a new angle, the world shifting beneath their feet.




5 Responses I Am Not What I Am: Orson Welles’ Othello (1952)
Posted By James : April 29, 2014 3:57 pm

I caught a screening at Film Forum a few days ago, and was dazzled. The visual ideas and mis-en-scene are amazing, and the acting (even Welles) is surprisingly subdued, pitched consistently in a lower key, which is an interesting contrast to some of Welles’ other films. It’s worth noting, though, that the re-recorded score sounds absolutely modern and not something authentic to a movie made in 1952. My ear picked up on that immediately; it was quite jarring.

Posted By Doug : April 29, 2014 9:35 pm

Consider this an ignorant comment, but my take on Welles has been than he could never get out of his own way-he was his own patron,
his own greatest fan who applauded first and loudest in admiration of the Genius Orson Welles.
He was great, no doubt. He created some amazing films, and as an actor he could hold an audience spellbound. But if he had been leavened with some humility early on, he could have been even better.
I would like to see this production, and let me point you towards Joss Whedon’s “Much ado About Nothing” done at his house
over the course of a week starring his version of the Mercury Theater faithful, friends from the ‘Whedonverse’. It’s pretty darn good.

Posted By James : April 29, 2014 11:31 pm

I liked Much Ado About Nothing, but Whedon had Avengers money, which enabled him to make it. Welles never had a fraction of that kind of income (and the film industry was very different, in those days, particularly Hollywood, where salary is concerned).

I don’t think Welles ever got in his own way. Hollywood studio executives consistently tampering with his films (for the worse), is another story. Except for Citizen Kane (where he was given final cut). As for humility, he was a consistent supporter of civil rights for many years, long before it was fashionable. Among other worthy causes he supported.

Posted By robbushblog : April 30, 2014 12:19 am

You’ve been deemed “Essential” by TheDissolve.com: http://thedissolve.com/news/2106-read-on-april-29s-essential-film-writing/

Posted By swac44 : May 2, 2014 11:59 am

Reading this piece made me curious about what soundtrack was used for the version Criterion released on laserdisc back in the ’90s, and sure enough they stuck with Welles’ original music and mix, digitally refurbished as well as possible at the time. It also has an audio commentary with Bogdanovich and others, and as far as I know, they haven’t released this edition on DVD/BD (the only one I could find on Amazon was an import from overseas).

And the liner notes are by…Jonathan Rosenbaum! They’re basically an edited version of the piece RMS linked to in his post, but adjusted accordingly for the laserdisc release, and Criterion has helpfully posted them on their website:


Leave a Reply

Current ye@r *

We regret to inform you that FilmStruck is now closed.  Our last day of service was November 29, 2018.

Please visit tcm.com/help for more information.

We would like to thank our many fans and loyal customers who supported us.  FilmStruck was truly a labor of love, and in a world with an abundance of entertainment options – THANK YOU for choosing us.