Musings from an Avid Soap-Opera Fan
It appears ABC wasn’t forthcoming with its complete rationale behind the cancelling of its soaps. Just weeks after the announcement regarding All My Children and One Life to Live, rumors and news leaked that the shows were picked up by a company called Prospect Park, a two-year-old media and production company that will produce them online. Prospect Park was portrayed as the savior of the soaps, and ABC seemed magnanimous for licensing the shows to them. However, former Disney head Rich Frank is a cofounder of Prospect Park, raising suspicions that this plan has been in the works for at least two years. (ABC is owned by Disney.) By portraying PP as heroic in the entertainment press for rescuing the two shows from ABC’s garbage heap, the new “online network” secures the loyalty of fans who are famous for their allegiance to their shows. Smells like a marketing plan to me. ![]() CHARLES DICKENS: THE GREAT-GRANDFATHER OF SOAP OPERAS? I AM SURE LITERATURE PROFS ARE TEARING THEIR HAIR OUT. Though moving the two soaps online will alienate older fans less impressed/enamored with the high-tech nature of online viewing, it is the tradition of the genre to adapt and adopt the latest distribution format, which attracts new markets. The serialization of narratives is generally traced back to the early 1830s when Charles Dickens released his first novel The Pickwick Papers in magazine installments, increasing sales of the tabloid in which it appeared from 14,000 to 40,000 during its run. In 1837, Dickens was hired to edit Bentley’s Miscellany where his novel Oliver Twist was serialized over the next two years. The serialization of his novels in journals for which he served as editor was used as a deliberate strategy to sell more magazine copies and more books. In the early 1910s, pioneer filmmakers such as Gene Gauntier began to specialize in writing and producing serialized adventures in which viewers were treated to one installment per week in theaters, with most episodes concluding with a cliffhanger to ensure the return of audiences the following week. While serials were a staple of Hollywood until the 1940s, the medium of radio was ideal for the conventions of the genre. Serialization is a narrative format that features a continuous cast of characters in a continuous dramatic storyline. Because commercial radio was broadcast daily, it was a perfect medium for a continuous story. In fact, the story could be never-ending, evolving based on the comings and goings of the characters—or the actors playing those characters. My adopted home town of Chicago was instrumental in the development of the soap-opera radio serial. In 1930, former schoolteacher Irna Phillips created the first daytime radio serial, Painted Dreams, for WGN in the Windy City. The narrative involved the widowed Mother Moynahan and her ongoing problems with her two children; it starred Ireene Wicker and Phillips herself, who acted out the simple domestic-based scenarios in 15-minute episodes. Three years later, two advertizing executives in Chicago, Frank and Anne Hummert, created three radio shows that would define the soap opera, Just Plain Bill, The Romance of Helen Trent, and Ma Perkins. Instead of adventure tales, these shows offered a combination of reality and romantic fantasy that spelled melodrama and then adapted it to the more intimate medium of radio, which reached out to audiences in their own homes every day. The premises seemed to present a slice of life because they showcased problems with love, marriage, family, and children, but the Hummerts dished it out with a heavy coating of fantasy, romance, and sentiment. For example, the title character in The Romance of Helen Trent was a glamorous Hollywood dress designer. ![]() 'PAINTED DREAMS' IS CONSIDERED THE FIRST SOAP OPERA, THAT IS A SERIALIZED MELODRAMA THAT WAS BROADCAST. Later in the decade, Irna Phillips returned with two new creations, The Road to Life and The Guiding Light. While still heavy on sentiment and romance, Phillips’s soaps focused on character more than story, creating characters with recognizable personality traits whom audiences counted on to act in a given way no matter the direction of the story. Her shows also featured professionals, such as ministers, nurses, and doctors, whose central morality eventually steered them in the right direction whether tackling a problem at home or on the job. And, the stories grew out of the characters’ jobs or personalities, making them more grounded in the everyday world than the soaps of the Hummerts. During the Depression, when about 40 million women listened to the 15-minute melodramas daily, the serialized dramas were used to advertise household products, including detergent. They were tagged “soap operas,” a name that stuck over the years. By the early 1950s, television had been networked so that it was possible to broadcast a show from coast to coast. The radio serials attempted to switch to the new medium. Many of them failed because they did not take the properties of television into account. Television is a visual medium, so descriptive dialogue, which weighed down character interaction, had to be replaced by direct communication in the form of conversation. Also, the intimacy of radio, in which characters are telling listeners a story in the comfort of their homes, needed to be translated to the small screen. The successful transplants from radio, such as The Guiding Light, recreated the intimacy by constructing sets that represented the homes of the characters, particularly kitchens where problems and emotions poured out of characters as quickly as coffee out of a pot. As television evolved and advanced, soaps grew to 30 minutes and expanded their premises. In 1963, General Hospital was created by Frank and Doris Hursley as daytime’s answer to prime-time’s glut of hospital shows. While diseases, operations, and medical jargon added authenticity to the show, the Hursleys delved into the dark side of human behavior by exploring stories of infidelity and rape. Irna Phillips created Another World, which was intended as a psychological melodrama that chronicled the characters’ inner turmoil, motivations, and reasoning. Realizing she needed help with this type of writing, Phillips hired young Agnes Nixon to be her head writer. Nixon went on to develop All My Children and One Life to Live, which gained reputations for tackling issues—abortion, rape, gay characters, AIDS—that prime-time producers treated with kid gloves. If AMC, OLTL, and GH hope to survive online, they will need to adapt to the characteristics of the medium in addition to keeping abreast of changes in social attitudes, like successful soaps have done in the past. Of course, the Internet as a story-telling medium is so new, I wonder if the execs at Prospect Park even know what the properties of the medium are. In many ways, television was the perfect medium for the soaps. With the daily flick of a knob, viewers tuned into to see continuous stories with familiar characters. No matter how many episodes a viewer might miss, it was easy to catch up through built-in updates interspersed in conversation among the characters. And, the charismatic actors under contract to the soaps—not unlike movie stars in the old studio system during the Golden Age—created loyal fan bases by adding nuances to their characters’ personas as the story arcs evolved. Because soap acting is broad, nonfans tend to look down on it as “bad acting,” but performances in melodrama are always broad; it’s the nature of the genre. The television soap opera was a terrific medium for two types of actors: (1) newcomers who needed the kind of experience and seasoning that only on-the-job training can provide; and (2) senior actors deemed over-the-hill by the film industry who could elevate the soap material with their charisma and professionalism. Over the years, AMC, OLTL, and GH have jump-started the careers of many well-known prime-time and film actors, and they gave senior-aged stars an opportunity to display their experience and talents without resorting to playing doddering old fools. I have noticed a few online articles in the past few days listing the stars who got their starts as characters on AMC, including Sarah Michelle Gellar (Buffy, the Vampire Slayer; The Grudge), Josh Duhamel (Las Vegas; Transformers: Dark of the Moon), Kim Delaney (Army Wives), and Eva LaRue (CSI: Miami). But, these barely-researched articles don’t even scratch the surface. It was AMC that first introduced Regis Philbin’s cohost Kelly Ripa to daytime viewers. Ripa played Hayley Vaughn, one of patriarch Adam Chandler’s many offspring. For a couple of years Hayley was paired with Charlie Brent, who was played by young Christopher Lawford, Peter’s son. Long before Oscar winner Kathy Bates terrorized James Caan in Misery, she terrorized Erica Kane as convict Belle Bodelle. Another Oscar-winner, Melissa Leo, who won best supporting actress last year for The Fighter, played Linda Warner during the 1980s. Character actor Ed O’Neill, who is currently enjoying success on the Emmy-winning Modern Family, appeared on AMC when he was 24—so long ago that it’s difficult to find the character he played. More recently, Mischa Barton of The O.C. briefly played Lily Montgomery. Established actors who appeared on AMC at the end of their careers include Arlene Dahl, Kim Hunter, Gloria DeHaven, and most famously, Ruth Warrick. Warrick, who played the first Mrs. Kane in Citizen Kane, starred as the conniving Phoebe Wallingford on AMC for 34 years. Another original character, Palmer Cortland, was played by James Mitchell, a choreographer and dancer who had appeared as the disgruntled boyfriend of Cyd Charisse in Vincent Minnelli’s The Band Wagon. Actors like Warrick, Dahl, and Mitchell lent the show the glamor and class of old-school Hollywood. Over the years, One Life to Live also started the careers of several future stars, including Tom Berenger, Tommy Lee Jones, Ryan Phillippe, and Mario Van Peebles. Many actors who achieved prime-time stardom learned the ropes on OLTL. Before playing Clair Huxtable on The Cosby Show, Phylicia Rashad was Courtney Wright on OLTL. Handsome Blair Underwood earned considerable success on L.A. Law, but he was known to soap fans as OLTL’s Bobby Blue. Jessica Tuck bears her teeth as the head vampire on True Blood, but she bore her sole as Vicki Buchanan’s long-lost daughter Megan. Other OLTL alum include Hayden Panettiere, Marcia Cross, Fisher Stevens, and Rainn Wilson. Veteran actor of Hollywood westerns Philip Carey (Gun Fury; Calamity Jane: They Rode West) ruled the roost for 20 years as One Life to Live patriarch Asa Buchanan. General Hospital has been on the air longer than All My Children and One Life to Live, so perhaps it is fitting that it will be the last to go. GH has introduced its fair share of future stars, from Leonard Nimoy (Bernie, c. 1963) to Demi Moore (Jackie Templeton, c. 1982-1983). When most of my friends saw Star Wars for the first time and wondered aloud at the unknown actors, I looked at Mark Hamill and said, “Hey, it’s Kent from General Hospital.” And, many of us had crushes on handsome John Stamos and Shaun Cassidy who played Blackie Parrish and Dusty Walker. GH gave opportunities to many prime-time stars, such as Richard Dean Anderson (McGyver), Emma Caulfield (Buffy, the Vampire Slayer), and James Sikking and Daniel J. Travanti (Hill Street Blues). For a while, the show had a tradition of giving singers an opportunity to act: Shaun Cassidy, Ricky Martin, and Rick Springfield. GH has given a lot of veteran female film stars one last spotlight to shine in, including Rosalind Cash, Arlene Dahl (who appeared on all three ABC soaps), June Lockhart, and Stella Stevens. Of these, Anna Lee, who was one of John Ford’s favorite actresses, enjoyed a 25-year run as Lila Quartermaine. (When ABC Vice President of daytime, Brian Frons, fired Lee in 2004, she died a short time later of what cast mates called a broken heart. Wonder if Frons has even heard of John Ford?) The latest grand dame of GH is Constance Towers (The Horse Soldiers; Shock Corridor) who lends a lethal combination of class and menace to the role of Helena Cassadine. Like many soap viewers, I inherited my soap habit from my mother, and, no matter where I lived or how my life changed, we shared a fondness for our “stories.” I latched on to my specific soap, General Hospital , in the third grade, because it was the favorite of my best friend Barb, who was much more worldly than I was. Tradition tells me that the serialized drama will continue to adapt to changing times and new mediums, but I fear the Golden Age of the television soap opera is over. 16 Responses Musings from an Avid Soap-Opera Fan
Excellent article! I didn’t know all about the Chicago connection in the early years of radio soaps — fascinating! I agree that ABC disingenuousness about the disposition of their soap operas was vast and obvious. I knew long ago that they were planning on changing over their SoapNet cable channel– which features replays of current soaps plus other interesting historical soaps like “Ryans Hope” (which is now off the channel, evidently, as of today) — into a kids network, which is happening soon. All the better to influence young minds, eh, with another TV network to train their future loyal viewers of Disney product. We all know that nothing lasts forever, but ABC had it out for the soap operas for a long time. The phony tributes and empty words of praise they heaped on AMC as they lowered the headsman’s axe were pretty hard to take. That story about Anna Lee was horrible, and I don’t doubt it was true. Please…in Hollywood with all its vast fortunes and profits, there isn’t a place for an older demographic? And I’m not even that much of a fan of soaps, but I was very fond of “Ryans Hope” back in the day, and also got caught up into “AMC” during my college years. A long time ago, but even I could relate to your post because of the long historical panorama that is a soap opera. Thank you for this great tribute. Soap fans everywhere should read this and pay tribute to this unique art form that is biting the dust, at least on American TV. I won’t be paying tribute to this art form myself that much, because it became trite and phony and didn’t reflect the real lives of the real people that watched it that much for the past half century-where in North America is the equivalent of the British soaps Coronation Street, Emmerdale [formerly Emmerdale Farm], or East Enders? All of these shows have real people with real problems and who compared to the characters on American soaps look just as real as you or I. These are the kind of shows that the soap opera producers should have been emulating, but they never bothered to do so, with the result that the shows are now being cancelled due to low viewership, whereas the British soaps are still garnering big ratings and fans. Perhaps the American producers, instead of escaping the problems inherent in the writing and acting of their shows by simply moving them to the Internet, should be checking out how their British cousins do soaps, and then maybe soap operas would make a comeback on TV, Until then, I’m afraid that it’s still going to be adios for soap operas in North America. I find it truly amazing that there is no place for soaps on daytime television. We have dozens of channels dedicated to sports: a baseball channel, a football channel, a golf channel, and on and on. Yet there is no place for soap opera. Do they really think we need another cooking show? There are already several channels dedicated to cooking and food. Thanks for the post. That was a nice, little history lesson about the soap opera. I will have to forward it to my sister. She has been a GH devotee for years and was a huge Guiding Light fan as well. Growing up with three sisters I often got stuck watching soaps. I wouldn’t mind watching them every now and then because some of the actresses were beautiful. I hadn’t seen any of them in about 15 years until I recently caught a clip of GH and saw that it was shot on digital video. It looked terrible. I guess that was a cost cutting move to slow the demise of the genre. If that was the case they probably should have ended it sooner. You know, like when that old quarterback or boxer tries to prolong their career well past the expiration date? It’s painful to see Joe Namath and his bad knees in a Rams uniform. Babe Ruth in a Braves uniform? Weird. All due respect to Fantomex, but I don’t think the ritz and glitz of American soap operas is what caused their demise. I just think American women’s tastes changed. They just stopped caring to watch serialized daytime programming. The most popular nighttime shows typically have single episode storylines. Serialized shows seem to get canceled much more quickly. Also, women have much more to do outside of the house these days. Most women work. They don’t have time for daily serials. I may be wrong. That’s just the way I see it. Also, in addition to all of those former soap stars, Nathan Fillion, of Firefly and Castle was on One Life to Live in that year long window in which I watched it. And wasn’t MacDonald Carey, star of Shadow of a Doubt on one of the recently canceled shows? While I am sure there is some ratings drop for the soaps, I don’t think it is as dire as claimed. I think methods for gathering data have changed. Women who work generally tape or DV-R their shows, or watch them on Soapnet–which makes it difficult to gather data on viewership. I think the Disney folks at ABC wanted to maximize profits,cost-cutting soaps by throwing them online and filling soap time slots with cheap talk shows. I am not buying their party line about sinking viewership. Disney and ABC has been lying about their plans for their soaps for two years; why should we believe them now. Dukeroberts: I should have mentioned Nathan Fillion. He’s a good actor. Catch him in TRUCKER if you get a chance. MacDonald Carey was the patriarch of Days of Our Lives, an NBC soap, until 1993. Fantomax: I am sure English audiences are as devoted to their style of soaps as American women are of theirs. I think American soap viewers are accustomed to melodrama that falls just this side of fantasy. I have to admit I prefer the glamor and glitz of America soaps. To paraphrase Joan Crawford: If I wanted to see the real people next door, I would just go next door. I’ve never been a soap watcher, but anyone who’s a David Sedaris fan will sooner or later come to respect the medium. I have no idea of why you’d want to make them realistic- the nature of the way they’re produced, all written in a huge rush and crammed together without the actors even having time to memorize their lines, doesn’t seem like it lends itself to staid, realistic drama nearly so well as it lends itself to completely crazy, nigh avant-garde kind of gilded corpse writing. It’s a shame to know that they’re dying, and it does seem kind of suspicious- but my guess would be that it’s largely because the networks have almost no interest in viewers outside the 18-45 demographic, and that soaps don’t do well with that market. Which seems a shortsighted way to make decisions, to me. Oh the soaps! I was a fan of the ones that aired on CBS. My neighbor girl watched The Young and The Restless and I soon was watching when I was 13, even my dad got hooked on it, asking me each day what had happened to Ashley, Jack, and Mrs. Chandler, who I think is still on and is Corbin Benson’s (actor of LA Law fame and now on Psych)mom in real life. On Guiding Light, Kevin Bacon played heartthrob, teen with angst, Philip Spalding, and leaving the show to make movies hasn’t proven to be a bad career move. My grandma’s each had a favorite show, Days of Our Lives, and yes, MacDonald Carey was on that show, my Grandma would always point him out to me and I think he was the voice introducing the show each week,”…like sands in the hourglass, so are the days of our lives.” My other grandma favored As The World Turns,which helped Meg Ryan get her acting footing. Funny you should mention that demographic, Tom S. because my soap-watching days fall within those years: as a young girl watching As the World Turns and The Guiding Light with my mother and Dark Shadows with my grandmother. Then as a college student it was General Hospital, as a 23 yr. old waitress it was Days of our lives that co-workers would tape and we’d watch at their place after closing the restaurant. I have such good memories of those times with my mom, grandma and those friends and those soap characters. I fully agree with Suzi that I love the glitz, the glamour, the over-the-top scenarios, impossible relationships— it’s fun, captivating escapism and best when shared. It is only now as a working mom, that I watch less television than I ever have. And I’d love to tell Disney that the LAST thing kids & parents need is another tv network! OR cooking show. OR talk show. Lisa W. makes a great point about the community aspect of watching soaps. I have to say I feel sorry for young viewers who watch soaps on their laptops — or anything on their laptops for that matter. It’s so isolating and how can you learn to appreciated another’s tastes and viewpoints if you watch everything in isolation. I remember vividly being in grad school in film studies when General Hospital was the soap of choice because of the Luke and Laura sensation. A dozen of us watched faithfully everyday. When the first Luke and Laura story arc ended with a shootout scene shot in a montage style, we actually stood up shouting “montage, montage.” We were so excited to recognize an edgy technique in a conservatively shot show. Watching the soaps together was a great way to relax after a day of classes. A great post on a sad time for soap opera fans. I watched GH from the 70s to about 2005, when the writing and treatment of the veteran stars and the fans was abysmal. We tuned in again when the new head writer started this year and are hoping for a turnaround. Sadly, there seems to be no hope for that on television. One can hope the soaps adapt and thrive online. Sad, though. Suzi, this is a more in-depth, personalized overview of the serialized drama. I especially am simpatico with you about Prospect Park’s dubious honor of “saving” AMC and OLTL. Reading the history of the serialized drama made me go back in time to when I used to fall asleep to Mystery Theater on the radio. I miss those radio dramas, which forced listeners to use their imagination to fill in the blanks. I’m afraid we’re all as a society headed down an advanced technological, ADD road where the next, big, fast thing will never be enough, rendering simple human interaction “boring.” With reality-TV, they’re already treating interaction like a necessary evil, speeding up the conversations so they can get to the titillating action (violence, sex, plot over character and substance). It’s like we’ve all been slowly trained like addicts to expect quicker, faster, more meaningless shock value highs. I think it shall hit me a year later just what a loss AMC is to me. It was my first introduction to Americana as a Korean immigrant. I also inherited my soap habit from my mother and grandmothers. I can remember as a little girl watching AMC with my mother and hear trying to keep my 4 year old attention span in check by saying ” let’s listen to what Nick is going to say to Erica…”. AMC was my “family”. It was always comforting to unwind at the end of the day with Pine Valley and it’s many colorful residents. I am livid that ABC pulled the plug on AMC and OLTL…..and as some people have said, I hope The Chew chokes. And to add insult to injury I am also annoyed at Disney for turning SoapNet into another Disney Channel for kids…as of there aren’t enough of those. I will follow AMC online even though that whole deal is shady. Running down the list of All My Children alumni, I’m surprised you forgot Eileen Herlie, Queen Gertrude to Olivier’s Hamlet, and Myrtle Fargate for more than 30 years to the rest of us. Leave a Reply |
Archives
Featured Sites
Popular terms
3-D
Action Films
Actors
Actors' Endorsements
Actresses
animal stars
Animation
Anime
Anthology Films
Autobiography
Avant-Garde
Aviation
Awards
B-movies
Beer in Film
Behind the Scenes
Best of the Year lists
Biography
Biopics
Blu-Ray
Books on Film
Boxing films
British Cinema
Canadian Cinema
Character Actors
Chicago Film History
Cinematography
Classic Films
College Life on Film
Comedy
Comic Book Movies
Crime
Czech Film
Dance on Film
Digital Cinema
Directors
Disaster Films
Documentary
Drama
DVD
Early Talkies
Editing
Educational Films
European Influence on American Cinema
Experimental
Exploitation
Fairy Tales on Film
Faith or Christian-based Films
Family Films
Fan Edits
Film Composers
Film Criticism
film festivals
Film History in Florida
Film Noir
Film Scholars
Film titles
Filmmaking Techniques
Films of the 1980s
Food in Film
Foreign Film
French Film
Gangster films
Genre
Genre spoofs
Guest Programmers
HD & Blu-Ray
Holiday Movies
Hollywood history
Hollywood lifestyles
Horror
Horror Movies
Icons
independent film
Italian Film
Japanese Film
Korean Film
Leadership
Literary Adaptations
Martial Arts
Melodramas
Method Acting
Mexican Cinema
Moguls
Monster Movies
Movie Books
Movie Costumes
Movie locations
Movie lovers
Movie Magazines
Movie Reviewers
Movie settings
Movie Stars
Movies about movies
Music in Film
Musicals
New Releases
Outdoor Cinema
Paranoid Thrillers
Parenting on film
Pirate movies
Polish film industry
political thrillers
Politics in Film
Pornography
Pre-Code
Producers
Race in American Film
Remakes
Revenge
Road Movies
Romance
Romantic Comedies
Russian Film Industry
Satire
Scandals
Science Fiction
Screenwriters
Semi-documentaries
Serials
Short Films
Silent Film
silent films
Social Problem Film
Spaghetti Westerns
Sports
Sports on Film
Stereotypes
Straight-to-DVD
Studio Politics
Stunts and stuntmen
Suspense thriller
Swashbucklers
TCM Classic Film Festival
Tearjerkers
Television
The British in Hollywood
The Germans in Hollywood
The Hungarians in Hollywood
The Irish in Hollywood
The Russians in Hollywood
Theaters
Thriller
Trains in movies
Underground Cinema
VOD
War film
Westerns
Women in the Film Industry
Women's Weepies |
Thanks so much for this lament for the vanishing soap opera. In addition to the actors, think of all the technicians who will now be without work. Brian Frons, the ABC VP, has few admirers among soap fans.
Loved the picture of the young Tommy Lee Jones with Lee Warrick, who played his wife on OLTL. OLTL made African-American and Jewish characters prominent in its early years. Lee Patterson of TV’s SURFSIDE 6 was an early leading man. Farley Granger was on for a bit in the 80s.
Another AMC alum who made a brief splash in movies was Karen Lynn Gorney, who played Travolta’s girlfriend in SATURDAY NIGHT FEVER.