As noted earlier this month in the Personal Journal section of the WSJ, there haven’t been very many sports-related movies nominated for a Best Picture Oscar.  While the sport of boxing has received the most attention from the Academy, only two other sports have had more than a single nominee among the year’s best over its 82 year history:  America’s former and current pastimes – baseball and football, respectively.  Last year’s dramatization of football’s Michael Oher story – The Blind Side (2009) – just received a nomination, but was likely aided by Sandra Bullock’s performance (and nomination for Best Actress) and the fact that AMPAS increased the number of nominees from 5 to 10 for the first time since 1943, when Casablanca (1942) won.

During the Academy’s tenure, only 14 of 479 (less than 3%) nominees for Best Picture – arguably its most vaunted, certainly its most remembered and discussed if not always most acclaimed category – have been sports-related movies despite the inherent drama in stories like that of Jim Braddock (Cinderella Man (2005)), which failed to earn a BP nomination.  One can only speculate whether The Champ (1931) – one of eight nominees for the top award that year, Here Comes Mr. Jordan (1941) and even The Pride of the Yankees (1942) would have been nominated if the Academy had limited the category to 5 nominees, as it did from 1944 through 2008.

But a more interesting question might be:  which sports movies “woulda, coulda, shoulda” been contenders if there had been 10 Best Picture nominees in their respective years?

First, an accounting of the sports-related movies that did receive Best Picture nominations (and won):

Boxing:  The Champ (1931), Here Comes Mr. Jordan (1941), From Here to Eternity (1953), Rocky (1976), Raging Bull (1980), Million Dollar Baby (2004)

Football:  Heaven Can Wait (1978), Jerry Maguire (1996), The Blind Side (2009)

Baseball:  The Pride of the Yankees (1942), Field of Dreams (1989)

Cycling:  Breaking Away (1979)

Horse Racing:  Seabiscuit (2003)

Pool:  The Hustler (1961) – this was on the WSJ’s list (I didn’t know pool was considered a sport!)

Running/Track:  Chariots of Fire (1981)

As you can see, my definition of “sports-related” is that a sport is integral to the story, e.g. Jack Lemmon’s character using a tennis racquet to strain spaghetti for Shirley MacLaine’s doesn’t qualify The Apartment (1960), however Prewitt’s refusal to box for his army unit is a key element in From Here to Eternity’s plot.  One could also argue that the sport of swimming (and even sailing too) is an important part of the Oscar winning Ordinary People (1980).

Here are some films that I believe might have been nominated for a Best Picture Oscar had the number of nominees been 10 (instead of 5) in their year of eligibility (with an obvious bias towards movies that the Academy recognized with at least one nomination in another category):

Horse Racing

National Velvet (1944), which was subsequently added to the National Film Registry; it received five Oscar nominations – winning two, including for Anne Revere (Supporting Actress), just two years after the change from 10 to 5

The Black Stallion (1979), also added to the National Film Registry, it won a Special Achievement Award and received two other nominations, including one for Mickey Rooney, Supporting Actor

Baseball

Damn Yankees! (1958), which received a nomination for Best Music, Score

The Natural (1984), was nominated in four other categories and included Glenn Close’s third consecutive Supporting Actress nomination

Bull Durham (1988), which received a Best Writing, Original Screenplay nomination

Basketball

Hoosiers (1986), added to the National Film Registry; it received two nominations, including one for Dennis Hopper (Supporting Actor)

Boxing

Body and Soul (1947), won for Best Editing; earned a Best Actor nomination for John Garfield and its Original Screenplay

Champion (1949), won for Best Editing; earned a Best Actor nomination for Kirk Douglas and a Supporting Actor nomination for Arthur Kennedy, another for its Screenplay to go with two others

The Set-Up (1949), a highly regarded drama featuring Robert Ryan, likely hurt by the presence of the more mainstream Champion (1949), but did win two awards at the Cannes Film Festival, one of which was for its director Robert Wise

Somebody Up There Likes Me (1956), this Rocky Graziano biography featuring Paul Newman won two Oscars and was nominated for another

Cinderella Man (2005), Ron Howard’s Braddock bio featuring Russell Crowe and Renée Zellweger received three nominations, including one for Supporting Actor Paul Giamatti

Before anyone comments that I could have included City for Conquest (1940) or Gentleman Jim (1942), two of my favorite boxing movies, they should realize that both were released in years that there were 10 Best Picture nominees and that neither was nominated in any category.

Pool

The Color of Money (1986), Paul Newman finally won his Best Actor Oscar, plus three other nominations

Rugby

This Sporting Life (1963), included Best Actor and Best Actress nominations for Richard Harris and Rachel Roberts

Tennis

Strangers on a Train (1951), Hitchcock’s thriller was nominated in the B&W cinematography category

Wrestling

The Wrestler (2008), which earned Mickey Rourke (Best Actor) and Marisa Tomei (Supporting Actress) nominations

Honorary mentions:

Football’s Remember the Titans (2000) and Olympic Hockey’s Miracle (2004) – how does this movie’s editing not get nominated?, because both stories transcend sport

Other worthy and/or nominated sports-related movies:

Auto Racing

Cars (2006) – which could have been like this year’s Up (2009) – nominated for Best Picture , but was instead nominated in the Animated Feature of the Year category

Baseball

The Stratton Story (1949) – won a writing Oscar

It Happens Every Spring (1949) – earned a writing nomination

Bang the Drum Slowly (1973) – for which Vincent Gardenia earned a Supporting Actor nomination

The Bad News Bears (1976)

A League of Their Own (1992)

The Rookie (2002)

Bowling

The Big Lebowski (1998)

Boxing

The Harder They Fall (1956) – received a nomination for its cinematography

Requiem for a Heavyweight (1962)

The Hurricane (1999) – for which Denzel Washington received a Best Actor nomination

Ali (2001) – which earned Will Smith a Best Actor nomination and Jon Voight a Supporting Actor nomination

Football

The Longest Yard (1974) – received a Best Editing nomination, but comedies are also rarely nominated for Best Picture

Rudy (1993)

The Express (2008)

Golf

Caddyshack (1980)

Hockey

Slap Shot (1977)

Karate

The Karate Kid (1984) – which earned Pat Morita a Supporting Actor nomination

Tennis

Match Point (2005) – Woody Allen received a writing nomination

Lest we forget:  Pat and Mike (1952) – although that year featured several other essentials that didn’t receive a Best Picture nomination:  5 Fingers, The Bad and the Beautiful, Come Back, Little Sheba, and Singin’ in the Rain; The Great Race (1965), and The Endless Summer (1966) … and one could make a case for Trader Horn (1931), big game hunting, or even possibly The Sting (1973).