Robert Ryan: Men In War (1957)

Robert Ryan

This is part of our week-long tribute to Robert Ryan, whose centennial is being celebrated on TCM today and tomorrow with a varied selection of his work. Check the schedule!

Robert Ryan looks exhausted in Men In War, Anthony Mann’s spare Korean War drama. He focuses all of his energy on curling his upper lip, slitting his eyes, and furrowing his brow, as you see in the photo above. He’s worried, tired, broken. He delivers the dialogue with a laconic flatness, never rising above a low rumble. His Lt. Benson confronts a dead soldier with the same intonation as he does a busted radio: “This war, you’re either healthy or you’re dead”. He continues doing his job out of inertia, prodded on by the desperate stares of his men. His weary resignation shifts into a bitter nihilism before the final battle, and Ryan handles the transition by adding a tremolo to his voice and taking off his helmet, revealing his matted-down mop of hair. Working with Mann, it’s a masterful bit of sepulchral underplaying, keyed to the battered landscape and the canny enemies that hide inside it.

Robert RyanBased on Van van Praag’s WWII novel, Day Without End (1949), and adapted for the screen by Philip Yordan (in collaboration with the blacklisted Ben Maddow, who is uncredited), Men In War follows Lt. Benson and his unit as they are cut off from central command and try to fight their way out from behind enemy lines. They are joined by the amoral Sergeant Montana (Aldo Ray) and his Colonel (Robert Keith), who has been shell-shocked into silence. All of these men are literally disconnected, as the opening scene finds the radio man repeatedly calling for help as Mann pans over a smoky, desolate horizon. No answer. This opening shot sets up the soldiers’ growing alienation from the army, and the incipient danger of the landscape, from which Mann and cinematographer Ernest Haller (who does fine foggy work) will wring a series of compositions emphasizing the North Korean’s mastery of the terrain. Manny Farber:  “…the terrain is special in that it is used, kicked, grappled, worried, sweated up, burrowed into, stomped on.”  Mann focuses on boots in mud and “threading lines at twilight” that emphasis the physical toll of battle. Nature is synonymous with death, and it shows in every crease on Ryan’s brow.

Mann cements this early on, in a rhyming composition between a dead, slumped over soldier, and Ryan’s resting body in a foxhole. These shots occur back-to-back:

BodyRobert Ray

Ryan is the walking dead, and so are his men, but they move on. While American bodies are slumped and lifeless, devoured by their surroundings, their Korean adversaries show off their knowledge of the terrain:

Men In WarMen In WarMen In War

They have all the tactical advantages, while Ryan’s men start to reach a hysterical pitch of complaining. There are two central conflicts, one between Benson and Montana, and the other between soldier and landscape. Montana is a shoot-first, take-no-prisoners type, whose fearlessness and brutality saves lives and bruises Benson’s already wounded nobility. Benson is trying to maintain a code of honor, but events keep spiraling out of control, with Montana’s smiling head pulling a trigger to solve the problem. Benson demands that Montana take a prisoner – and he guns him down instead. When Benson inspects the body, he discovers a pistol in the hat that would probably have taken him down. Montana simply wants to get his Colonel home safe, this doddering old man the only thing left in the world that he values. Army protocol takes a beating here, which drew the ire of the U.S. Armed Services, who publicly condemned the film and refused any assistance in its production, from on-set experts to weapons and ammunition.

The Benson-Montana showdown plays out in a rather predictable manner, but Ryan and Ray imbue it with enough bleary resignation and childish psychosis, respectively, that it’s an effective microcosm of the broader drama of man versus nature. The only sense in which Mann allows these soldiers a measure of control is in his obsessive inserts of hands – especially in the exchange of cigarettes. These close-ups show the miniature world in which Benson can gain control of. Outside, Montana is overthrowing his ethics and the DPRK Army will soon overrun his men. And eventually the world right in front of their eyeballs face the reality of blood and dog tags:

Robert RyanMen In WarRobert Keith and Aldo Ray's HandRobert RyanRobert Ryan

Men In War is not playing as part of TCM’s celebration, but it is available on Netflix, who carry the out-of-print Geneon disc, which is a poor transfer of a decent print, or in a French version from Wildside, which received good marks from the smart guys at DVD Beaver.

0 Response Robert Ryan: Men In War (1957)
Posted By suzidoll : November 10, 2009 6:21 pm

From watching GOD’S LITTLE ACRE, I found that Ryan and Ray worked well together. The two films were made back to back, I think.

Does Aldo Ray go shirtless in MEN IN WAR like he does in GOD’S LITTLE ACRE? If he did, that would make a great double bill!

Posted By suzidoll : November 10, 2009 6:21 pm

From watching GOD’S LITTLE ACRE, I found that Ryan and Ray worked well together. The two films were made back to back, I think.

Does Aldo Ray go shirtless in MEN IN WAR like he does in GOD’S LITTLE ACRE? If he did, that would make a great double bill!

Posted By Al Lowe : November 11, 2009 8:24 am

I am fortunate enough to have a lot of the movies being discussed as part of my VHS collection, including Men in War and The Iceman Cometh. I was impressed not only by Ryan and Aldo Ray but by Robert Keith, as the shell shocked colonel; his son was Brian Keith. This movie has the worst closing theme song I ever heard in my life. Note to Suzie: I don’t know if Aldo takes his shirt off. I’m a guy, so I didn’t notice.

Posted By Al Lowe : November 11, 2009 8:24 am

I am fortunate enough to have a lot of the movies being discussed as part of my VHS collection, including Men in War and The Iceman Cometh. I was impressed not only by Ryan and Aldo Ray but by Robert Keith, as the shell shocked colonel; his son was Brian Keith. This movie has the worst closing theme song I ever heard in my life. Note to Suzie: I don’t know if Aldo takes his shirt off. I’m a guy, so I didn’t notice.

Posted By Robert Kawasaki : November 23, 2009 6:31 am

MEN IN WAR is reportedly director Anthony Mann’s personal favorite. Mann thought he could invest every asset of his personal beliefs into this film. Raw psychology of fighting men, dynamism of landscape and a conflict between two different moral standards. Beyond any doubt MEN IN WAR is those things. The film is the most simple war tale which I have ever seen. Yet, it is sometimes more powerful and solid than ATTACK! or PATHS OF GLORY. We don’t see any domineering generals, flash back family memory of the soldiers, smart tactics, or phony patriotism. A platoon was cut off from bigger outfit in unknown Korean land, and the platoon must make effort to rejoin the big stuff for its survival. Consequently, the film offers us an almost endless march of exhausted soldiers. Of course we will see some actions including shooting, bambing, exploding, and attacking along the way, but they are treated with quite restrained manner, so that the entire texture of the film remains strangely calm and even beautifully meditative. I would say that is quite unique and innovatively original for a war film, and I believe that is why MEN IN WAR is a great masterpiece. By encountering this silence yet dreadful atmosphere, we are able to sense meaninglessness of war, and stupidity of mankind. Furthermore, the film itself does not make any ovbious judgement, and this uplifts the film to a philosophical art. Lt.Benson, a leader of the platoon, played by Robert Ryan, is a steady officer who tries to do everything to save his men, however he mercilessly confiscates a jeep from an unwell colonel and his subordinate. Sgt. Montana, the opponent of Benson, played by Aldo Ray, is a deserted soldier with rude attitude, but he sincerely respects his unwell colonel. These two deliver excellent performances and they have succeeded to project the film’s depth and sophisticated ambiguity. MEN IN WAR persuades us to make our own reasoning of mankind. So, I must admit the film is an existential masterpiece from its director and Anthony Mann was a great philosopher indeed.

Posted By Robert Kawasaki : November 23, 2009 6:31 am

MEN IN WAR is reportedly director Anthony Mann’s personal favorite. Mann thought he could invest every asset of his personal beliefs into this film. Raw psychology of fighting men, dynamism of landscape and a conflict between two different moral standards. Beyond any doubt MEN IN WAR is those things. The film is the most simple war tale which I have ever seen. Yet, it is sometimes more powerful and solid than ATTACK! or PATHS OF GLORY. We don’t see any domineering generals, flash back family memory of the soldiers, smart tactics, or phony patriotism. A platoon was cut off from bigger outfit in unknown Korean land, and the platoon must make effort to rejoin the big stuff for its survival. Consequently, the film offers us an almost endless march of exhausted soldiers. Of course we will see some actions including shooting, bambing, exploding, and attacking along the way, but they are treated with quite restrained manner, so that the entire texture of the film remains strangely calm and even beautifully meditative. I would say that is quite unique and innovatively original for a war film, and I believe that is why MEN IN WAR is a great masterpiece. By encountering this silence yet dreadful atmosphere, we are able to sense meaninglessness of war, and stupidity of mankind. Furthermore, the film itself does not make any ovbious judgement, and this uplifts the film to a philosophical art. Lt.Benson, a leader of the platoon, played by Robert Ryan, is a steady officer who tries to do everything to save his men, however he mercilessly confiscates a jeep from an unwell colonel and his subordinate. Sgt. Montana, the opponent of Benson, played by Aldo Ray, is a deserted soldier with rude attitude, but he sincerely respects his unwell colonel. These two deliver excellent performances and they have succeeded to project the film’s depth and sophisticated ambiguity. MEN IN WAR persuades us to make our own reasoning of mankind. So, I must admit the film is an existential masterpiece from its director and Anthony Mann was a great philosopher indeed.

Leave a Reply

Current ye@r *

As of November 1, 2017 FilmStruck’s blog, StreamLine, has moved to Tumblr.

Please visit us there!

http://filmstruck.tumblr.com/tagged/streamline-blog

 Streamline is the official blog of FilmStruck, a new subscription service that offers film aficionados a comprehensive library of films including an eclectic mix of contemporary and classic art house, indie, foreign and cult films.