Plan 9 @ 50

Plan 9 poster

Eros, the earth people are getting closer to that which we fear.  Since they will not listen or respect our existence, they cannot help but believe our powers when they see their own dead walking around again, brought about by our advancement in such things.  As soon as you have enough of the dead recruits, march them on the capitals of the earth.  Let nothing stand in your way.  Their own dead will be used to make them accept our existence… and believe in that fact.

Of course, it’s impossible to turn back the hands of the clock but in this silver anniversary year of Ed Wood’s PLAN 9 FROM OUTER SPACE (1959), I’ve been trying to remember what it felt like before I knew this was “the Worst Film of All Time.”  Now before I go any further, I should state (as I have before) that I consider PLAN 9 to be not only not the worst film of all time but also not even the worst Ed Wood film of all time.  That particular allegation and dubious honor came courtesy of THE GOLDEN TURKEY AWARDS (Pedigree Books, 1980) by Harry and Michael Medved.  (A year earlier, the brothers’ FIFTY WORST FILMS OF ALL TIME had neglected Wood and PLAN 9 entirely.)  With heat-seeking snark, les freres Medved not only singled out Wood’s magnum opus for derision but branded its maker “the worst director of all time” to boot.  Of course, Wood was dead by this point and not likely to kick.  For those who had never seen the movie in question, the Medved’s proclamation (based on an open vote they had called for in the end pages of THE FIFTY WORST FILMS OF ALL TIME) stamped PLAN 9 FROM OUTER SPACE with a reputation that has endured to this day, although it might be argued that the authors’ boorish, high-handed dismissal of the film did nothing so much as to introduce it to a whole new generation of B-movie fans eager to find out for themselves… “how bad could it be?”

Cold Clay

I suppose I first saw pictures from PLAN 9 FROM OUTER SPACE in the pages of FAMOUS MONSTERS OF FILMLAND magazine.  Ed Wood knew FM editor-in-chief Forrest J. Ackerman and peppered him with letters over the years, announcements of his latest projects and irons in the fire.  I wonder know if Forry only ran pictures from PLAN 9 to get Ed Wood off his back but whether 4SJ liked or didn’t like the movie he gave it the royal treatment in his magazine.  To a 10 year-old kid, PLAN 9 looked like the coolest movie ever.  The imagery was crisp, the shadows were as black as Cola Cola, and the monsters were really scary… at least in picture form.  I mean, look at Tor Johnson in the frame grab above, rising from his grave inside a cone of light that seems to have been mounted in the casket.  Nobody but Ed Wood would have thought to light the coffin from inside!

Tor_Johnson

When I was a kid and saw these images for the first time, I thought Tor Johnson was the scariest monster ever.  The trouble with most movie monsters, from a terror standpoint, is that their faces too often reflect recognizable human emotions.  Dracula was cunning, Frankenstein’s monster vulnerable, the Wolfman enraged… but Tor Johnson’s “Big One” perfectly embodies (and enfaces) the absence of human emotion, the terrible emptiness of death… the true definition of a zombie (non-flesh-eating).  When I was in college, I spent $25 on an official Don Post Tor Johnson full-head mask and used it to scare my roommate.  I hid in his closet and waited for him to return from campus.  Going to hang up his coat, he opened the closet door, saw me, took a breath and SCREAMED, long and high-pitched, like a tea kettle.  Then he took another breath and SCREAMED AGAIN.  Twenty five bucks well spent.

vampira

And Vampira … when I was 10, I don’t think I’d ever seen a sexier woman.  (And I should point out that I had unlimited access to my Dad’s cache of PLAYBOYs.)  Vampira strolled the fine line between alluring and repulsive with catwalk precision.  Finnish model Maila Nurmi had created her cadaverous alter ego for the purposes of a 1953 Hollywood costume contest, in which she entered herself as Morticia Addams.  A producer for KABC-TV spotted the self-professed intimate of James Dean and tagged her to be a late night horror hostess.  The gig lasted but one season and soon Nurmi was back looking for work… and Ed Wood was hiring.  Though Nurmi had higher aspirations – and there had been at one point major studio interest in her – she was by this time so broke that there was no recourse for her but to accept Wood’s offer of $200 a day.  Nurmi’s only request was that she be allowed to play the part mute.  Well, the result speaks for itself.  Countless Goth queens have patterned themselves after the late horror hostess (who entered eternity in January 2008) but there’s no bettering the original.  She really is immortal.

Laugh all you want (no, really… yuk it up, I don’t mind).  PLAN 9 FROM OUTER SPACE carries a release date of 1959, the same year as John Cassavetes’ SHADOWS.  The Cassavetes film, self-financed and shot guerilla style on the streets of Manhattan, is widely considered to be a seminal tract in the history of American independent films but there’s little done by Cassavetes, pioneer though he may have been, that Wood hadn’t done first.  (PLAN 9 was shot for the most part in 1956, while all footage featuring Bela Lugosi was filmed somewhat earlier.)  Filming on the fly, mixing nonprofessional actors with more seasoned performers, and the reconstitution of standard Hollywood tropes in what feels like a looser-knit, more experimental affect all point ahead to the techniques of the French New Wave.   It seems these days almost anybody can claim the title of indie filmmaker, especially with the advent of digital photography, but back when you had to lug an old Mitchell around town it took some doing.  Love him or hate him, Ed Wood did it.  He did it without the Internet, he did it without MySpace, Facebook, Twitter or viral marketing.  He did it without buzz, 100% sweat equity.  His results may never have lived up to his aspirations but he did complete nine feature films and a number of short subjects, as well as unsold TV pilots, over the sourse of twenty exceedingly odd years.  I think in our Psychotronic rapture, we’ve failed to give Ed Wood the credit he is due as an indie trail blazer.  I’m not trying to elevate the man above his station or try and make some postmodern argument that bad is good but it’s worth entering into evidence that his movies are nothing if not unique – Wood’s ear for dialogue was certainly his own (“Inspector Clay’s dead.  Murdered.  And somebody’s responsible.”) – and that we’re still discussing them half a century later should count for something.  I’m lucky, I guess.  Forty or so years after I first heard of PLAN 9 FROM OUTER SPACE, I not only still like it; I probably like it more now than I did then.  The spooky shots of Vampira and Tor Johnson doing their zombie walk is still creepy to me and Wood’s anti-armament stance, an openly critical view of American bellicosity and entitlement in the Eisenhower era (and this from an ex-Marine who saw combat in the South Pacific) strikes me now as incredibly brave.  So at the end of the first fifty years of PLAN 9 FROM OUTER SPACE and a full generation past Ed Wood’s sad and lonely death in a North Hollywood rental on December 12, 1978, I feel a genuine fondness for and an incredible gratitude to the man who predicted before I was born that future events would affect me in the future.  They certainly have.  Thanks for the warning, Eddie, and Happy Birthday PLAN 9!

15 Responses Plan 9 @ 50
Posted By Marty McKee : July 10, 2009 12:12 pm

I watch this every year at B-Fest, where it has become something of a ROCKY HORROR PICTURE SHOW phenomenon with props (paper plates!) and shoutbacks to the screen. It’s all good fun though, and I believe that almost everyone has a fondness for the picture, rather than just mocking it to be cool. One key is that many of the key players get a round of applause when their name comes up in the opening titles (although poor costume designer Dick Chaney is subjected to boos and taunts–not his fault he shares his name with the most hated VP in modern U.S. history!).

I think the scene between Lyle Talbot and Bill Ash (?) in Talbot’s office has got to be the single dullest scene in the history of cinema.

Posted By Marty McKee : July 10, 2009 12:15 pm

Tom Keene, not Bill Ash.

Posted By Kelly : July 10, 2009 1:09 pm

Isn’t it funny how many of the films that are slapped with the “worst” label are actually quite enjoyable?

PLAN 9 is a seminal entry in the annals of schlock, and definitely a “must see” for anyone interested in B-movies. As much as I esteem PLAN 9, I think my favorite would have to be MANOS, THE HANDS OF FATE (1966) because of its ridiculously endearing level of amateurism.

Posted By Greg F : July 10, 2009 1:15 pm

Great post. I wonder if it’s connected to a blogathon, like the Spirit of Ed Wood Blogathon going on over at Cinema Styles. Probably.

Boy, I can tell you, even though I started the whole thing off with a defense of Wood and Plan 9 I never thought so many others agreed. I agree with Marty that the military office scene is dreadful but it’s incredibly useful in pointing out that that is what bad is, not the rest of the movie.

Another point I made in a Styx post was that his movies were pretty much average, semi-well made movies. It’s just that he didn’t do retakes so they come off looking like blooper reels but his pacing is genuinely good and he’s not bad with lighting either.

Posted By suzidoll : July 10, 2009 5:29 pm

I saw PLAN 9 a year ago on the big screen on a double bill with BRIDE OF THE MONSTER. The audience had such a good time.

But, beside that, I noticed something that I had not thought of before. Wood understood standard continuity editing, which is the foundation of Hollywood filmmaking and a hallmark of craftsmanship. His action makes sense, he generally does not cross the axis line, direction is matched from shot to shot, action is matched from shot to shot, and like Greg F. mentions above, the films have a decent sense of pacing. In terms of logic and clarity, Wood’s editing has more craft to it than Michael Bay’s brain-numbing chaos will ever have. That’s why it is easy to watch Wood’s stuff more than once, despite the horrific acting and bottom-of-the-barrell set design.

Posted By franko : July 10, 2009 7:39 pm

I loved this movie as a kid and I still love it as a, well, “big” kid. I always thought the Medved boys were too full of themselves to have the right to criticize any film, and I believe their slamming of what today are beloved cult films has finally come home to bite ‘em on the ass. I know lotsa folks who recognize the name of Ed Wood but have no idea who the Medveds are. Poetic justice, imho.

Posted By morlockjeff : July 10, 2009 10:33 pm

In the spirit of a PLAN 9 anniversary celebration, I humbly submit a “what if” cartoon panel depiction of the first eight plans from outer space and why they failed -

go to this link

http://www.tcm.com/2008/underground/lostscenes.jsp and click on “view all lost scenes at the bottom” and then click on “see what’s inside” and FINALLY click on the title PLAN NINE FROM OUTER SPACE and you’ll see the first page.

Posted By john august smith : July 11, 2009 4:31 pm

Fans of Plan 9 should try to see VooDoo Man/1943. John Carradine’s acting in this film makes Bela Lugosi look like John Barrymore.The plot if any think is more stupid.

Posted By Parker Benchley : July 11, 2009 7:09 pm

Film critic Michael Weldon got it right, Plan 9 is not the worst movie ever made, but the most entertaining one you’ll ever see.

Posted By M.X. Palidan : July 12, 2009 8:47 pm

I enjoyed the blog and all the responses. I lived and worked in Hollywood for years and visited where the interiors were shot(Western & Santa Monica werehouse)and quick city exteriors. Much has changed since Ed filmed there, but some is recognizable. I often wonder where the “graveyard” exteriors in San Fernando were shot. I’m sure there is either a shopping mall or an apartment complex there now. If anyone knows the exact locale, please post it.

When the movie ED WOOD came out in 1994, a number of people made “pilgrimages” to the Hollywood sites of not only Plan 9

Posted By M.X. Palidan : July 12, 2009 8:53 pm

[I accidently hit the "submit" buttom, so I'll finish up the above comment] — …but to Ed’s living places and bar hangouts. At that time I worked as a script reader for a medium size film company and his script THE GHOST GOES WEST was making the rounds. As I recall, with some rewrites it could have been an amusing film, but the company passed on it. Too bad someone else didn’t pick it up.

Posted By Richard Harland Smith : July 13, 2009 11:29 am

I often wonder where the “graveyard” exteriors in San Fernando were shot.

If I remember correctly, the cemetery was up in/around Sacramento, where Tor Johnson’s son Karl was a police officer. In fact, at the time of shooting (1956) the cemetery was in the process of being torn up to allow for building of something else, which is why Wood et al were allowed to film there. Karl Johnson also wrangled some official cop cars for the picture.

Posted By M.X. Palidan : July 13, 2009 4:03 pm

Thanks for the info. Since PLAN 9 was such a low budget I just figtured Wood & Company stuck to filming around L.A. Perhaps this explains why the central office of “The Church of Ed Wood” is in Sacramento, not Hollywood.

I correct myself about the script that was making the rounds back in the early 90′s. It was THE GHOUL GOES WEST, not THE GHOST GOES WEST.

Little is known of Kathy Wood after Ed died. We know she didn’t remarry and passed away in 2006. I knew a journalist in 94 who was researching her life for an article, but ran into roadblocks. He did track her down to living in a classic old Hollywood apartment in the Cahuenga/Yucca area, near where her and Ed lived for many years. She was very private and even after going through a mutual friend she refused an interview.

If anyone could help fill some of the blanks there concerning Kathy Wood it would contribute to the ongoing “Ed Wood Legend”.

As for “the worst film ever made”, PLAN 9 is far from that. I would nominate MESA OF LOST WOMEN(1953) starring Jackie Coogan as being in the top ten. Seeing that virtually unwatchable stink bomb on a big screen straight through one risks getting temporary or permenent eye damage!!

Posted By MovieWatcher : July 15, 2009 5:15 am

This is one of the bad movies that will keep you laughing all night, all because it wasn’t ment to be funny the director ment it to be serious, and the death of the old man who was first brought back, and his replacement that was shorter by two feet, and the fat man unable to get out of the grave, and! the many more fantasticly tarible things that make this movie just that much worse and that much funnyer. I think that the best part of this whole movie is the U.F.O’s that are attached to fish string wobling around and the man being told in the plane “don’t tell anyone about this” then the flight attendent walks in and asks whats happening, the the captin says come, look, theres a U.F.O outside the wondow.

Posted By Andrew T, Smith : July 15, 2009 10:29 am

I completley agree with the statement that Plan 9 is not the worst film of all time and certainly not Wood’s worst.

The thing that always dazzles me about Wood films is how personal they are. I would even go so far as to call him an auteur, at least during his prime.

Leave a Reply

MovieMorlocks.com is the official blog for TCM. No topic is too obscure or niche to be excluded from our film discussions. And we welcome your comments on our blogs and bloggers.
Archives
Popular terms
3-D  Actors  Actors' Endorsements  Animation  Anthology Films  Awards  Books on Film  British Cinema  Character Actors  Chicago Film History  Cinematography  Classic Films  College Life on Film  Comedy  Comic Book Movies  Czech Film  Dance on Film  Digital Cinema  Directors  Disaster Films  Documentary  Drama  Early Talkies  Editing  Educational Films  European Influence on American Cinema  Exploitation  Family Films  Film Composers  film festivals  Film Noir  Film Scholars  Filmmaking Techniques  Food in Film  Foreign Film  French Film  Gangster films  Genre spoofs  Guest Programmers  HD & Blu-Ray  Holiday Movies  Hollywood lifestyles  Horror  Horror Movies  Icons  independent film  Italian Film  Literary Adaptations  Martial Arts  Melodramas  Method Acting  Mexican Cinema  Monster Movies  Movie Books  Movie locations  Movie Stars  Music in Film  Musicals  Outdoor Cinema  Parenting on film  Polish film industry  political thrillers  Pornography  Pre-Code  Producers  Race in American Film  Remakes  Road Movies  Romance  Romantic Comedies  Russian Film Industry  Scandals  Science Fiction  Screenwriters  Semi-documentaries  Short Films  Silent Film  silent films  Social Problem Film  Sports  Sports on Film  Stereotypes  Straight-to-DVD  Studio Politics  Suspense thriller  Swashbucklers  TCM Classic Film Festival  Television  The British in Hollywood  The Hungarians in Hollywood  The Irish in Hollywood  The Russians in Hollywood  Theaters  Underground Cinema  VOD  War film  Westerns  Women in the Film Industry  Women's Weepies